• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
The Relief

The Relief

  • Facebook
  • Flickr
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • Medical
    • Claim Status
    • What’s Covered
    • Eligibility
    • Change Dependents
    • Prescriptions
    • Find Medical Care
    • LiveHealth Online
    • Wellness Plan
    • Medical Equipment
    • Medicare
    • Long-Term Care
    • Vision
    • ID Cards
    • Kaiser Plan Member
    • PPO Summary Plan Document (SPD)
    • Medical Forms
    • Transparency in Coverage
  • Relief Benefits
    • Firefighter Event Reimbursement Form
    • Medical Equipment
    • Sick & Injury
    • Life & Accident
    • Death Benefit
    • Family Support Group
    • Assistance / Advancements
    • Estate Planning/Trusts
    • Scholarships
  • Ten Bells
    • Death Notices & Funerals
    • Report a Death
    • Member Deaths – A to Z
  • Retirement Corner
    • Scheduled Retirement Events
    • Retirement Announcements
    • Plan a Retirement Event
    • How To Retire
  • Calendar
    • Special Fundraisers
    • Events
    • Retiree Breakfast / Lunch Reunions
    • Memorials / Funerals
    • Firefighter Event Reimbursement Form
    • Add an Event
  • Grapevine
    • Current Issue
    • Articles
    • Columns
    • Mailbox
    • President’s Message
    • Advertising
    • Submit an Article/Photo
    • Archives
  • Donate
    • Donate Now
    • Widows & Orphans Web Site
  • About Us
    • About The Relief
    • Contact Us
    • Careers / Employment Opportunities
    • Board of Trustees
    • Testimonials

Retiree Health Subsidy Lawsuit

September 30, 2014

gv_oct-2014_health-subsidy-lawsuitRecently several websites and individuals have been putting out information concerning the case entitled Fry v. City of Los Angeles. Fry is the case brought against the City of Los Angeles by the Los Angeles Retired Fire and Police Association (LARFPA) and four of its members. (The case has been identified as Fry by the courts because that is the last name of the first individual specifically named in the lawsuit.) The information presented here will serve to better and more accurately explain the current status of the case.

LARFPA brought suit against the City challenging two ordinances passed by the City Council in 2011 impacting the retiree non-Medicare health subsidy (retiree health subsidy) administered by the Los Angeles Fire and Police Pension System. On July 28, 2014, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Joanne O’Donnell handed down a ruling on Fry.

Judge O’Donnell ruled that the ordinance implementing a freeze of the retiree health subsidy for members not agreeing to pay an additional two percent in pension contributions was an illegal impairment of a vested pension benefit under state law. In her ruling, O’Donnell stated that a writ would issue against the City on this issue. (A writ is an order requiring the losing party to take an action. In this case the order would be to overturn the freeze.)

The City tried to defend the freeze by pointing to the “opt-in window” the City offered during which time members in Tiers 1 through 5 could buy back an unfrozen retiree health subsidy by making an additional two-percent pension contribution. Judge O’Donnell ruled that the “opt-in” offer did not save the freeze because the opportunity to buy back a vested right did not offer members any new advantage to offset the impact of the freeze. However, the judge said that she would not order the City to pay back the 2% contributions already made. Instead, she referred that part of the case to a different court. The other court will decide whether the City has to refund the two percent contributions already collected from members who opted in.

Judge O’Donnell also stated in her ruling that the retiree health subsidy was indeed a vested pension benefit, as the LARFPA has publically stated from the beginning.
Finally, the judge refused to order the City to guarantee future increases in the retiree health subsidy. Instead she stated the discretion to provide future increases would remain with the Board of Fire and Police Pension Commissioners.

As of August 28, 2014, Judge O’Donnell has not issued the actual writ. The LARFPA, through its attorney, has asked Judge O’Donnell to issue a writ that does two things: (1) directs the Board of Fire and Police Pension Commissioners to set future retirement health subsidy levels without regard to the invalid freeze ordinance, and (2) stops the City from continuing to collect two percent salary contributions from members who opted in. The City and the Pension Department have filed papers stating that only the first item—setting future subsidy levels without regard to the freeze–should be included in any writ. Once a writ issues, the City can appeal it to a higher court.

Once a writ issues, the LARFPA will notify our members immediately.

The Los Angeles Retired Fire and Police Association is made up of dues paying retired members and active members with 20 or more years of service. The LARFPA is the only organization dedicated to protecting the pension rights and benefits of both active and retired members of the Los Angeles Fire and Police Pension System.

By Ken Buzzell, Director, Los Angeles Retired Fire and Police Association

Filed Under: Articles, Grapevine

Primary Sidebar

Paid Advertising

Share!

Gene Cooper – Born to Build

Generations – Part Cuatro

The Los Angeles Firemen’s Relief Association’s Holiday Dinner Dance

Secondary Sidebar

The Firemen's Grapevine

Categories

  • Articles (713)
  • Board Minutes (172)
  • Columns (185)
  • Department In Action (63)
  • Featured (85)
  • Health & Fitness (31)
  • Highlights (85)
  • Mailbox (64)
  • Memorials (27)
  • Retired Guys (33)
  • Sports (68)
  • Training (7)
Chris Stine

President’s Message – February 2023

Coming just after January, which is the month of new beginnings, is February. From the Latin word Februarius, meaning “to purify,” February was known as the “Month of Purification” during ancient Roman times. It is a … Continue Reading about President’s Message – February 2023

Archives

  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
  • 2012

Footer

Main Office Numbers
(800) 244-3439 Toll-free
(323) 259-5200 Direct

Office Location
7470 N. Figueroa St
Los Angeles, CA 90041

Los Angeles Firemen's Relief Association
  • Home Page
  • Contact Us
  • Links
  • All Forms
  • Staff Directory
  • Board of Trustees
  • By-Laws
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site Map

Give To A Hero

Widows, Orphans & Disabled Firefighter’s Fund
Donate Now

Copyright © 2023 · Los Angeles Firemen's Relief Association